L’Oreal Superliner Superstar review

Lise —  January 18, 2018 — 7 Comments


What is it?

Information from the UK website:


Transform your look in one daring stroke. Its specially designed felt tip fulfils your every wish. The ‘Corseted’ tip with a flexor system helps you to follow the natural contours of your eyes, boldly extending to the ends of the lashes. It’s showtime!

Ink Tank Tip: Releases ink over your lash line for perfect line control.

Flexor system: Adapts to every movement to modulate the thickness of the line in one effortless sweep.

Divine Black formula: Deep black and shiny finish.

With the precision tip of your SUPER LINER SUPERSTAR, apply from the inner to the outer edges of your upper lash line.

As you can see from the description, this is a felt tip liquid eyeliner from L’Oreal that claims to be deep black and shiny. It is supposed to give you super precision and it will glide over your eyes super easily. As you can see in the picture below it is definitely shiny and not matte.


How does it work?

It has a pretty good formula that dispenses well when I apply it and it gives a nice, crisp line. It was fairly easy to create a pointed wing like I use to do and it wasn’t messy to use at all. It did tickle my eye a little bit though because I’m used to using pencils and not any felt tip liners. The applicator isn’t too hard nor too flexible so you have very good control when applying it to your eyes. It is very pointy so it makes it easy to create a sharp wing on the outer corners of my eyes.


I haven’t read anything about it claiming to be smudge proof or waterproof and I’m glad they haven’t claimed it, because it really isn’t at all. My eyes do not water very often but the lower part of the wings were super smudged and faded by the end of the day. I didn’t really touch my eyes at all either but the black had faded a bit. Granted, I had been wearing it for about thirteen hours at that point. It does last for a long time but it could use a touch up around the ten hour mark.

Apart from all that, I’m quite happy with the liner overall. It doesn’t feel like it’s sitting on top of the skin like how some liquid liners does and it was very comfortable to wear. After a good few wears I noticed it was irritating my eyes a little bit though so I have given it a break. My eyes were stinging and it was not a good feeling at all.

So to sum it up:

+ It’s really black
+ It’s easy to apply
+ It’s drugstore and fairly cheap

– It smudges and fades fairly easily
– It’s not cruelty free
– It eventually started irritating my eyes

I will continue using it now and then until it’s empty or I get tired of it, but I will not repurchase it since it is not cruelty free.

Have you tried this liner? 

Pin it:

Kopi av Kopi av Copy of Copy of Copy of Copy of Copy of Brown Rustic Photo Home Pinterest Graphic (2)




I'm a 26 year old girl. I love blogging about things like make up, skincare, books, video games, life, home decoration, gardening and whatnot. I love getting to know new people, let's start a conversation!

7 responses to L’Oreal Superliner Superstar review


    Good review, love hearing and reading about pen eyeliners as they’re my go to to use! Annoyin it’s not smudge proof, something I really need as my eyes get irrated/water a lot. L’Oreal is a brand a struggle with because they have some products I love but aren’t crulety free which always makes me feel super guilty!xxx



    I use the same one. Its the voluminous superstar one and in love it! 🙂



    It’s a shame the eyeliner smudged. If you want smudge proof try collections extreme eyeliner. I use one from Primark which I love but it does smudge, the struggle is real.


Trackbacks and Pingbacks:

  1. Steve Laurant Liquid Liner Review « Lushtivity - February 15, 2018

    […] I haven’t had too much experience with felt tip liners, but after the failure that was the L’Oreal Superliner, I was ready to find an actual good […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s